Iran: UK must admit mistake

Iran's foreign minister Manouchehr Mottaki made the demand yesterday, as Britain condemned Tehran for "parading our people" in a video that showed the only woman captive saying her group had "trespassed" in Iranian waters.


The Iranian official also backed off a prediction that the female sailor, Faye Turney, could be freed yesterday or today, but said Tehran agreed to allow British officials to meet with the detainees.

Minister Mottaki said that if the alleged entry into Iranian waters was a mistake "this can be solved. But they have to show that it was a mistake. That will help us to end this issue".

"Admitting the mistake will facilitate a solution to the problem," he said late yesterday in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, where he was attending an Arab summit.

It was the first time that Iran has publicly suggested a way to resolve the crisis, but British acquiescence appeared unlikely.

In London, Defence Minister Des Browne denounced the video, saying: "It is completely unacceptable to parade our people in this way".

Britain will today seek approval from the United Nations Security Council for a statement that would "deplore" the detention of the sailors and call for their immediate release.

The statement being sought would also say the Britons were operating in Iraqi waters under a UN mandate at the request of Iraq, council diplomats said on condition of anonymity.

The British government earlier said it was freezing all dealings with Iran except to negotiate the release of its personnel, adding to a public exchange of sharp comments that helped fuel a spike in world oil prices.

Since the crisis began, Britain has insisted its troops were in Iraqi waters and released a GPS readout yesterday that it said proved the Royal Navy personnel were seized 1.7 nautical miles inside Iraqi waters.

But Mr Mottaki said Iran had GPS devices from the British boats that showed they were in Iranian territory.

The video – released yesterday, and shown on Iran's Arabic language satellite television station Al-Alam – showed sailors and marines sitting in an Iranian boat in open waters immediately after their capture.

The video also displayed what appeared to be a handwritten letter from Ms Turney, 26, to her family.

"I have written a letter to the Iranian people to apologise for us entering their waters," it said. The letter also asks Turney's parents in Britain to look after her three-year-old daughter, Molly, and her husband, Adam.

The video showed Ms Turney in checkered head scarf and her uniform eating with other sailors and marines.

Later, wearing a white tunic and black head scarf, she sat in a room before floral curtains and smoked a cigarette.

Ms Turney was the only detainee to be shown speaking, giving her name and saying she had been in the navy for nine years.

"Obviously we trespassed into their waters," Turney said at one point, her voice audible under a simultaneous Arabic translation.

"They were very friendly and very hospitable, very thoughtful, nice people. They explained to us why we've been arrested. There was no harm, no aggression."

In backing away from predictions that Ms Turney could be freed yesterday or today, Mr Mottaki said Iran would look into releasing her "as soon as possible".

He said earlier the reports of her imminent release were incorrect. "I was probably misquoted," he said.

After the footage was aired, Foreign Secretary Margaret Beckett said she was "very concerned about these pictures and any indication of pressure on, or coercion of, our personnel … I am particularly disappointed that a private letter has been used in a way which can only add to the distress of the families."

The third Geneva Convention bans subjecting prisoners of war to intimidation, insults or "public curiosity".

Because there is no armed conflict between Iran and Britain, the captives would not technically be classified as prisoners of war.

British Prime Minister Tony Blair yesterday told the House of Commons that "there was no justification whatever … for their detention, it was completely unacceptable, wrong and illegal".

"We had hoped to see their immediate release; this has not happened. It is now time to ratchet up the diplomatic and international pressure in order to make sure the Iranian government understands its total isolation on this issue," he said.

Ms Beckett said Britain would focus all its efforts on resolving the issue.

"We will, therefore, be imposing a freeze on all other official bilateral business with Iran until the situation is resolved. We will keep other aspects of our policy towards Iran under close review and continue to proceed carefully. But no-one should be in any doubt about the seriousness with which we regard these events," she said.

The statement appeared to refer to diplomatic dealings rather than business relations, but Britain's Department of Trade said the country does not buy oil directly from Iran.

Oil prices rose by more than $US1 a barrel yesterday to a six-month high amid worries about the standoff, which came as the US Navy is carrying out its largest show of force in the Gulf since the 2003 invasion of Iraq.

US President George W Bush discussed the 15 Britons with Blair over a secured video conference call yesterday, White House deputy press secretary Dana Perino said.

"The president fully backs Tony Blair and our allies in Britain," she said.

British officials have said the 15 Britons were taken captive after completing a search of a civilian ship near the mouth of the Shatt al-Arab waterway, which forms the border between Iran and Iraq.

In London, British military officials released new information about the seizure, saying satellite positioning readings showed the vessels were 1.7 nautical miles inside Iraqi waters.

Vice Admiral Charles Style gave the satellite coordinates as 29 degrees 50.36 minutes north latitude and 48 degrees 43.08 minutes east longitude. He said that position had been confirmed by an Indian-flagged merchant ship boarded by the sailors and marines.

He also told reporters the Iranians had provided a geographical position on Sunday that he said was in Iraqi waters. By Tuesday, he said, Iranian officials had given a revised position about 3km to the east, inside Iranian waters.

"It is hard to understand a legitimate reason for this change of coordinates," Style said.

Comments are closed.